
COP31 was billed as an implementation summit, with its Turkish presidency promising to move beyond climate commitments and accelerate practical action.
At the halfway point of COP31, there are signs of momentum, especially around electrification and clean energy. But we have been here before, and first-week momentum has fizzled out in week two when the practicality of getting heavy fossil fuel economies like Saudi Arabia and Russia on board meets reality.
As we reported, it was not off to the greatest start for the Turkish host, as when the discussion in the Turkish resort of Antalya centred around phasing out fossil fuels, in the Turkish capital of Ankara, the government was celebrating a major oil discovery.
But the last few years’ key bridging differences still remain largely unsolved: How quickly can countries move away from fossil fuels, who will pay for the transition, and will the countries most exposed to climate change receive the support they need?
The different assessments offered by the summit’s leading figures reflect both the ambition and the uncertainty.
At his final COP press conference on 13 November, the outgoing UN Secretary-General, the 77-year-old diplomat and politician, António Guterres warned that “the climate crisis is outrunning us”. He called for an accelerated, just and equitable transition away from fossil fuels.

Stiell to governments: Take on the hardest issues
The following day, the UN climate head, Simon Stiell, shared his take on proceedings halfway through. He urged governments to confront the hardest issues, warning that “no collective success” was possible without compromise from every Party.
In the same press conference, the COP31 President, the Turkish environment minister, Murat Kurum, repeatedly stressed the need for tangible results, saying the summit must be an implementation COP.
Meanwhile, the COP31 President of Negotiations, Australia’s climate and energy minister Chris Bowen, emphasised the need for countries to work together across the negotiating agenda.
They all point to the same conundrum: whether the political ambition being expressed in Antalya can be translated into decisions, finance and action, which, according to Stiell, can only be achieved if countries are willing to compromise.
Electrify everything, but how, what and where?
One of the presidency’s most visible initiatives is its 35-by-35 electrification pledge, which aims to increase electricity’s share of global final energy consumption from around 23% today to 35% by 2035.
The electrification drive is also a key agenda for the independent energy analytics and forecast body, the International Energy Agency (IEA).
Early this week, the Executive Director of the world’s most trusted energy outlook body, Fatih Birol, visited his birth country to argue for a clear global target that would send a clear signal to investors and markets.
Birol urged governments to accelerate electrification and presented it as a way to strengthen energy security and reduce exposure to volatile fossil fuel markets.
More than 50 countries publicly, in principle, showed support for the drive without locking themselves in on any specific targets.
The initiative is based on a strong economic and energy-security rationale. By electrifying transport and heating, industry as well as households can reduce dependence on imported oil and gas, while expanding access to reliable electricity.
But the electrification drive has an overarching big but: the energy sources that should generate this electricity have not been set out, and without locking down the energy sources, it could be gas- and coal-derived.
That is why the EU has added a red line in order to support it; it must be labelled clean electricity.
Guterres: electrification must mean a rapid expansion of renewable energy
Earlier in the week, Guterres had stressed that clean electrification must be accompanied by a rapid expansion of renewable energy, grids, storage and energy efficiency, and must drive down fossil fuel production and emissions.
In return, electricity generated from coal or gas does not deliver the same climate benefits as electricity generated from wind and solar.
John Kerry: The rest of the world should follow China
Similar sentiments were shared by John Kerry, who served as the US’s first climate envoy in the Biden Administration and the Secretary of State in the Obama Administration.
Kerry singled out China’s accelerating clean-energy deployment, arguing that the rest of the world, including the US, must follow its lead.
China’s expansion of renewable generation, electric vehicles and clean-energy manufacturing demonstrates the scale of the economic transformation already under way.
The country is in addition to being the world’s biggest consumer of fossil fuels is also the world’s biggest installer, generator and investor in clear energy technologies like wind and solar.
Therein lies the overarching challenge for COP31’s leadership – how to ensure that this transition is accessible to countries without China’s industrial capacity or the financial resources of wealthier economies.
There will be warnings that electrification cannot take priority over the elephant in the room: making progress on weaning the world off fossil fuels.
Climate finance: The test for developing countries
The gap between ambition and delivery is perhaps most apparent in climate finance. Developing economies are not only being asked to expand clean energy over fossil fuels, but also to strengthen infrastructure and adapt to increasingly severe climate impacts, often while facing high borrowing costs and limited fiscal space.
And the finance promised to many developing and least developing economies through the Green Climate Fund and other initiatives are still to materialise in the same capacity it was pledged.
During the first week of COP31, the President of the UN General Assembly, Annalena Baerbock, highlighted the scale of the challenge. She cited estimates that developing countries need up to $305bn annually for adaptation but currently receive only around $26bn. The figures underline how far existing support falls short of the resources required.
Guterres has called for developed countries to deliver at least $300bn a year in climate finance by 2035, alongside concrete plans to at least triple adaptation finance. He has also argued that the wider $1.3tn climate-finance ambition must translate into actual flows to developing countries, rather than remain a distant political commitment.
For the least developed countries and small island developing states, the issue is not simply the total amount of finance available.
The terms and how they can access these loans matters just as much. Loans can add to already unsustainable debt burdens, while complex application procedures and fragmented funding channels can prevent money reaching the communities that need it.
Voices within the UN and organisations and individuals working on financing climate adaptation are increasingly calling for reforming the system, dropping huge interests and loans as well as urge wealthy countries to forgive debts for vulnerable countries.
Subscribe to our weekly weekend newsletter:
The Weekend Edition!
Climate justice and the just transition
Climate justice is closely connected to the finance debate, but it also concerns who has a voice in shaping the transition and who benefits from it.
More than 700 organisations from 88 countries, representing trade unions, Indigenous Peoples, feminist movements, young people, farmers and environmental groups, have at COP31 for governments to establish a meaningful Just Transition Mechanism.
Their demand follows an earlier commitment to develop such a mechanism and reflects concern that the transition must protect workers, communities and livelihoods, rather than focus on emissions targets alone.
However, the first draft of the mechanism has already attracted criticism. Climate Action Network representatives warned that the proposals risk creating an institution without sufficient resources or powers to support workers and communities.
They have called for meaningful civil-society participation and practical support, rather than another process dominated by meetings and reporting.
Civil society groups have also questioned whether the electrification agenda will necessarily deliver a fair transition. Climate Action Network representatives from South America warned that electrification could reproduce existing inequalities.
That is, if it relies on fossil gas, extractive projects that damage Indigenous territories, or energy systems designed primarily around export markets and wealthier consumers.
Week two and the negotiations
After heads of state departed on Friday, negotiations could officially begin, and we are due to receive the first draft text on Monday, which would give a clear indication of where things stand as well as the direction of travel.
As with previous COPs, the future of fossil fuels remains one of the summit’s most politically difficult and controversial questions.
Several world leaders, including the host country of Australia, have been criticised for promoting their growth in clean energy while neglecting to acknowledge their continued investments in new fossil fuel projects.
At COP28, governments agreed to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems in a just, orderly and equitable manner. It was still a massive climbdown, as in the 11th hour, led by the petrol states, the text was changed from phasing out to transitioning away from fossil fuels.
Since then, progress on this issue has worsened, and it became a challenge even having some kind of reference to fossil fuels in the final agreement.
Last year at COP30, an alliance of countries wanting to push this agenda was formed with the view that it was best to pressure COP on this externally.
The first conference on Transitioning Away from Fossil Fuels was hosted by Colombia this year, with the second scheduled for July 2027 and to be co-hosted by Ireland and the small island state of Tuvalu, with it taking place in the climate-vulnerable island state.
Subscribe to our weekly weekend newsletter:
The Weekend Edition!
Little progress on bridging key disagreements
The first week in Antalya has not resolved these differences. Negotiators have made progress on some technical and procedural matters, but major issues have been carried into the second week.
Discussions on the Mitigation Work Programme, the Global Goal on Adaptation and the Just Transition Mechanism have exposed disagreements over mandates, the scope of future work and the level of ambition. Climate finance remains particularly contentious.
A proposed COP31 cover decision has also been the subject of consultations. The presidency’s published reflections document summarises issues raised by countries, including the 1.5°C temperature limit, climate finance, adaptation, loss and damage and electrification. It is not, however, an agreed negotiating text.
The challenge for Bowen and the negotiating teams is to turn these competing priorities into outcomes that countries can accept without weakening the commitments already made.
For Kurum, the test is whether the presidency can deliver the practical results it has promised.
What would success look like?
As COP31 enters its final week, the summit’s implementation ambition remains important, but it is not yet a measure of success in itself.
For key observers, a meaningful outcome would require more than endorsements of electrification targets or announcements of new initiatives.
It would need to demonstrate progress towards a credible transition away from fossil fuels, accelerate clean electricity and energy access, strengthen adaptation and resilience, and provide developing countries with finance they can actually afford and access.
It would also need to show that the just transition is more than a political slogan, with institutions and resources capable of supporting workers and communities.
In his final COP as Secretary-General, Guterres reminded governments that climate action is inseparable from development, peace and justice. His warning that countries cannot be expected to transform their economies while being denied the means to do so captures one of the central tensions facing the negotiations.
As we head into week two, the test of the week will show whether COP31 can begin to close that gap between ambition and delivery.
For the countries and communities already facing the greatest consequences of climate change, the distinction between a summit that promises implementation and one that delivers it is not a procedural matter. It is a question of survival, security and development.
Anders Lorenzen is the founding Editor of A greener life, a greener world.
Subscribe to our weekly weekend newsletter:
The Weekend Edition!
Related
Discover more from A greener life, a greener world
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.